About this piece

When the Fibre Fails: an animated side-by-side of load balancing (typical SD-WAN) and connection bonding in an office with three people and three carriers. When the fibre is cut, load balancing drops the call, fails the upload and loses unsaved work (0 of 3 working); bonding keeps all three working. Made by Munir Kotadia. Full description, screenshots and options: All the work, described.

Load balancing vs bonding

When the fibre fails, who stays connected?

One office, three people at work, three connections from three different carriers. Then the fibre line is cut. Watch what happens to each person's work.

Everyone working normally
Laptop traffic Phone call traffic Cloud app traffic

Load balancingAs used by many SD-WAN products: sessions go to the best line

3 of 3people working

The router sends each session to the best line, so all three run over the fibre while 4G and 5G sit idle. When the fibre fails, every session on it breaks: the call ends, the upload fails and the app loses unsaved changes. A few seconds later the router fails over and everyone starts again on 4G and 5G.

Connection bondingEvery packet, across every line, in one encrypted tunnel

3 of 3people working

Everyone's traffic is spread across all three lines at once. When the fibre fails, the 4G and 5G lines are already carrying the call, so it continues. Nobody has to reconnect.

← Munir Kotadia